Showing posts with label data mining. Show all posts
Showing posts with label data mining. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 20, 2013

Big data analytics will never replace creative thought


The claim expressed in the title of this posting is the title of  a piece in "Data Quality News" by Richard Jones.   It claims that the "data craze" - the conception that data mining alone is sufficient to get decisions in all areas, is a misconception in some areas.  Jones provides two examples:  marketing - where statistical reasoning gives a great value, but it deals with the small details, however  human creative thinking deals with the big picture, and data mining alone cannot get it,  and healthcare - again, data mining can be of great value, but interactions with the patient and personal examination by a physician is vital.    
I guess that the research into AI should also deal with how to create artificially creative thinking.  As I've written before Noam Chomsky has criticized the AI community by making statistical reasoning its mainstream and deserted the strive for  "solid model of the universe" .  I guess that after some disillusionment from the "data craze" the industry will settle on getting data mining its right place, as a supporting technology.

More on this - later.

Thursday, November 24, 2011

More on big data and event processing



Philip Howard, one of the analysts who follows the event processing areas for many years, recently wrote about "CEP and big data".    emphasizing the synergy of data mining techniques on big data as a basis to create real-time scoring based on predictive model created by data mining techniques, his inspiration for writing this piece was reviewing the Red Lambda product.   It is certainly true that creation of event processing patterns off-line using mining techniques and then tracking this event patterns on-line using event processing is a valid combination, although the transfer from the data mining part to the event processing part typically requires some more work (in most cases also involves some manual work).    In general getting a model built in one technology to be used by another technology is not smooth, and require more work.  
The synergy between big data and event processing has more patterns of use -- as  big data in many cases is manifested in streaming data that has to be analyzed in real-time,  Philip mentions Infosphere Streams, which is the IBM platform to manage high throughput streaming data.   The data mining on transient data as a source for on-line event processing, and the real-time processing of high throughput streaming data, are orthogonal topics that relate to two different dimensions of big data, my posting about the four Vs summarizes those dimensions.   

Saturday, May 28, 2011

On mining and detection of human sentiments

An exhausting week,  followed by over-sleeping during the weekend (our weekend is Friday and Saturday), and a 2.5 hours session with the dentist in the middle.


This week I heard in one of the IBM internal meetings some impression from a customer meeting in Europe.
The topic was data mining, and the insight has been that mining is trying to learn patterns based on the past behavior.   This works in some cases, but might not be enough in other cases; the reason is that in some cases what we actually need to learn is human behavior, and assuming that past behavior is a good indicator may be wrong, thus the domain should be extended to analyzing and predicting human sentiments and human behavior.   This is, of course, not a new area,  and the behavioral sciences people are studying it for years, one notable work is the work on prospect theory, that brought Daniel Kahneman the Noble prize (the co-inventor of the prospect theory, Amos Tversky,  passed away before the Noble prize was given, and the prize is being awarded to living persons only).   There are other works in this area, and some are being used in reality.    Getting multi-disciplinary work is quite important for enabling intelligent systems and enable predictive analytics.  More on this - later. 

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Some thoughts on data mining and event processing - take one


Somebody with whom I've talked to last week said with some irony that in order to get attention today - no matter what you do, you have to say that it has something to do with clouds, and that it performs some kind of analytics. Well - it is a clear bright day today here without any cloud, so I'll delay the discussion about clouds to rainy day.   As for analytics, there are various types of analytics, today I'll write something about data mining and event processing.  There are two sides here: what event processing can do for data mining, and what data mining can do for event processing.  Let's focus the discussion now about the second issue.  The answer seems easy,  an event processing application is modeled by event processing network, that consists of event processing agents, which in most current implementations are implemented by rules/queries or some other constructs.  Today the application is being composed manually using some authoring tool -  however, there is a frequently asked question, can the computer somehow use magic to compose the application itself -- this is a natural candidate problem for data mining.    The achievements of data mining in event processing until today are somewhat modest, but there still might be a promise there.


So - let's go further and explore the potential.   We can look at three types of functions  that an event processing application may be assisted by data mining:

  1.  Case in which we are looking for anomalies in general, the data mining can assist in identifying that we have anomaly now,  this is actually a different type of application in which there are no preset patterns.
  2. Case of  detect of trends/thresholds oriented, where the thresholds can be adjusted by data mining
  3. Case of pattern detection - where the patterns can be determined by data mining.


The first type is a classification issue - and this can be done by some types of learning of what is normal behavior. 

The second type -- learning thresholds also has some known methods in data mining.
The main problem is the third one -- learning patterns.   There are several difficulties there, the first one is the intent;  data mining typically discovers events that happen together, this by itself may not be of interest, since the aim of patterns are to detect situations that require reaction, thus there is some additional semantic knowledge here that is not captured by data mining without providing additional informations, furthermore the pattern may occur very rarely, such that it will not be captured within the existing data; another difficulty is the richness of pattern types and the various variations of patterns, so looking at the space of large possibilities.  
Successes in this area were typically limited to a certain type of pattern within a certain temporal window -- for example, there was some work that I familiar with to mine sequence of two events within a given temporal window, this again belongs to events that happen together, where a human has to go over all combination and decide whether they create an interesting situation.     


Bottom line -- no magic bullet,  but any breakthrough in this area will be helpful  

Wednesday, December 24, 2008

On Data Mining and Event Processing

Today I have travelled to Beer Sheva, the capital of the Negev, which is the south part of Israel, that consists mostly of desert. I have visited Ben-Gurion University, met some old friends, and gave a talk in a well-attended seminar on "the next generation of event processing". I have travelled by train (2 hours and 15 minutes each direction), and since my last visit there five years ago or so, they have built a train station from which there is a bridge which goes to the campus, very convenient. Since I am not a frequent train rider in Israel, I discovered that in both ends of the line, there are no signs saying which trains go on which track, and this is assumed to be common knowledge... Although they do notify when a train entered the station where it is going and from which track, but still they have a point to improve.

Since some of the people attended my talk were data mining people they have wondered about the relationships of event processing and data mining, since I've heard this question before I thought the answer will be of interest to more people.

In the "pattern detection" function of event processing, there is a detection in run-time of patterns that have been predetermined, thus, the system knows what patterns it is looking for, and the functionality is to ensure correct and efficient detection of the predetermined patterns.

Data mining is about looking at historical data to find various things. One of the things that can be found are patterns that have some meaning and we know that if this pattern occurs again then it requires some reaction. The classic example is "fraud detection", in which, based on mining past data, there is a determination that a certain pattern of action indicates suspicion of fraud. In this case the data mining determines the pattern, and the event processing system finds in run-time that this pattern occurs. Note, that not all patterns can be mined from past data, for example- if the pattern is looking for violation of regulations, then the pattern stands for the regulation, but this is not mined, but determined by some regulator and is given explicitly.

So - typically data mining is done off-line and event processing is performed on-line, but again, this is not true for all cases, there are examples in which event processing and mining are mixing in run-time. An example is: there is a traffic model, according to which the traffic light policies are set, but there is also constant monitoring of the traffic, and when the monitored traffic is deviating significantly then the traffic model has to be changed and the policies should be set according to the new traffic model, this is kind of mix between event processing and mining, since the actual mining process is triggered by events, and the patterns may change dynamically as the result of this mining process.

More - Later.